“My husband’s like, ‘That’s what’s so funny about how you played it. You really thought you were popular,’ “ the actress tells PEOPLE Toria Sheffield joined the PEOPLE editorial ...

If every party has a pooper, Sean Lowe's came from Father of the Bride. The Bachelor alum—dad to Samuel, Isaiah and Mia with wife Catherine Giudici Lowe—told E! why the 1991 flick had him weeping.