The 12-inch coal-fired pesto pizza at Ungaro's (Staten Island Advance/Lauren Lovallo) UNGARO —1298 Forest Ave., Port Richmond, 646-968-4777; Ungarocoalfiredpizzacafe.com Pies are beautiful with ...

The top-five vote-getters were Rustic Pizza & Pasteria, Staten Island Slice, Lorenzo’s Pizza of New York, Ungaro Coal Fired Pizza Cafe and Mimmo’s Brick Oven Pizza & Trattoria. 1. Rustic Pizza ...

Staten Island serves some of the most legendary pizza around, due to the borough's large population of Italians and Italian Americans. Below are our five favorite pizzerias. Some have been around ...