This peanut butter pie is amazing for any holiday, or even just a weeknight! It was a huge hit at our 4th of July celebration ...

For example, one post shows grainy photographs of Nutter Butter cookies in a dollhouse with peanut butter smeared everywhere, set to a spooky soundtrack. It looks like a peanut butter crime scene.

Shortly after debuting its Nutter Butter peanut cookies in 1969, Nabisco began airing cartoon ads starring a mascot called the Nutter Butter man-a Willie Wonka simulacrum who pranced around the ...