First, we covered the labels to prevent any bias among our panelists. Then we tasted each peanut butter straight from the spoon to assess its texture and flavor. We wanted our testers to make the ...

Ultimately, the choice is yours, but for the best pie texture, you'll want to go with smooth and creamy. Peanut butter pie isn't just a matter of dumping a jar of peanut butter into a pie crust.